Home » Reviews » Review: Photoshop CS2 (page 3)

Review: Photoshop CS2 (page 3)

Taking the (very little) bad with the good...

Like most large programs, CS2 does not do everything 100% perfect. There are a few areas where the function is provided, but is the performance is weak and best left to third-party plugins. Among these are noise reduction, sharpening, and in some cases image resizing. But once again, the included tools are more than serviceable for most users and most situations.


Bridge is an external application for managing your images.
Another feature I found missing was the ability to paste an item directly from the clipboard into a new image. Photoshop is smart enough to know there is image data in the clipboard and the New image dialog prefills in the sizing information based on that copied image. But then it is still a two-step process of creating a new image and then pasting the clipboard into that image. Everytime I have to do this, I get annoyed, but then it quickly passes once I'm immersed in the coolness of the application.

The major detriment to Photoshop CS2 for most hobbyist and semi-professional photographers is its hefty pricetag. It weighs in at about $650 for just PSCS2. You can pay more and get it as part of the entire Adobe CS2 Suite. Sadly this is the main reason Photoshop has been noted as one of the most pirated software packages ever. And while there is never a reason for stealing software, Photoshop CS2 offers quite a temptation and challenging test of integrity. Fortunately, Adobe has released most of the key Photoshop functions in the scaled down and affordable "Elements" series. But if you truly need the full features of CS2, especially for professional duties, the price tag is nothing compared to the benefits received.

Conclusion...

It should be noted that a few weeks from now, Photoshop CS3 will be released. No word has been made available on upgrade pricing of if there will be a window for free upgrades (purchases of CS2 after a certain date, yet before CS3 is released). But if you're in the market right now for a top of the line photo editor, your best bet is Adobe Photoshop CS2.



Strengths Weaknesses
  • Customizable interface options.
  • Attention to detail in user interface.
  • Many unexpected and helpful features & tools.
  • Industry standard, prompting large community support.
  • Some weak features, however supplemented by third-party plugins.
  • High price tag prevents (legal) entry-level users.
Reader Comments:
Add comment:
Name
Not a member or not logged-in.

Comment

Adobe FAN commented on March 14, 2007 20:03:
you still showing your ignorance of PS features in your (premature) review or you would not say this: But then it is still a two-step process of creating a new image and then pasting the clipboard into that image. Everytime I have to do this, I get annoyed, but then it quickly passes once I'm immersed in the coolness of the application.
Kevin L. Kitchens commented on March 15, 2007 00:22:
Thanks for the comments. However, I'm not sure what you mean. Is there a hidden, one step command to paste the clipboard into a new image? Also, CS2 is about to be replaced with CS3, so I'm not sure how this review could remotely be called "premature". :) Thanks again!
Will Smith commented on March 15, 2007 10:38:
This review seems biased, I see nothing worth the upgrade price honestly. CS is bloatware
Adobe Fan commented on March 16, 2007 16:20:
what I am saying is someone who has hardly used the program or previous versions cannot possibly understand why the workflow is created as it is, when you paste it becomes a new layer into an existing document or yes you need to make a new image. That is not a flaw.
Kevin L. Kitchens commented on March 17, 2007 09:54:
Thanks Adobe Fan for the clarification. I certainly did not mean to imply changing the existing paste function from what it already does so well. But like PSP where there is a separate "Paste as New Image" command. Thanks again for reading and checking back!
Bart Hickman commented on March 19, 2007 23:44:
Pretty brief review for such a complex product, but I agree with your sentiments. I switched from PSPX to CS2 about a year ago (after having switched from PS4 to PSP7 several years earlier) and had a similar experience. Besides the wonderfully rich feature set, an often-overlooked feature in CS2 is the sheer speed of operation which leaves all others in the dust and the gap widens exponentially as the pixel count increases beyond about 8mpixels. If you're a professional or a serious amateur and your ti
Bart Hickman commented on March 19, 2007 23:45:
Oops, I cut myself off. ...time is worth anything, then it's well worth the price (which gets a lot lower for upgrades.)


Page generated in 00.0000 seconds.

From the
POTD Archive

Click to view larger version.
Off to the Races
Don Beechey

Click to view larger version.
Stretching - Red-shouldered Hawk
Dean Graham

Click to view larger version.
The 5mm Elephant
Trevor Carpenter

Click to view larger version.
Dried Oranges
Mustafa Kizilcay

Click to view larger version.
My Worst Nightmare
Diane Kroupa

Copyright © 2000-2024 photographyvoice.com / PEI Development. All Rights Reserved.